Comment

Who will be India's spinner for the Tests in Australia later this year?

R Ashwin, Ravindra Jadeja or Kuldeep Yadav - who can take on the combined might of Steven Smith, David Warner and Marnus Labuschagne?

Ian Chappell
Ian Chappell
07-Jun-2020
Left-arm wristspinner Kuldeep Yadav took 5 for 99 in Sydney in the 2018-19 Test series in Australia  •  Cameron Spencer/Getty Images

Left-arm wristspinner Kuldeep Yadav took 5 for 99 in Sydney in the 2018-19 Test series in Australia  •  Cameron Spencer/Getty Images

Common sense suggests that given current circumstances, there's more likelihood of a Test series featuring India in Australia rather than of a T20 World Cup there. With the pandemic still lurking, it's far easier to provide a reasonably safe environment for one rather than 16 playing squads.
So what is the likely outcome of a series between the two Test heavyweights? India's historic away series win the last time these two teams met will be a far more difficult feat to repeat. The two big differences between the 2018-19 series and this one will be the presence of David Warner and Steven Smith, and an opening encounter at the infamous Gabbatoir.
I'm mystified why the Gabba is such a black spot for touring teams. The pitch is true and it's fair to all players. And yet Australia haven't suffered a Test defeat at the ground since 1988-89. The helter-skelter nature of modern scheduling, resulting in limited time to prepare for local conditions, could be one reason for the abject failure of touring teams in Brisbane.
If India are forced to isolate on arrival, it may turn out to be a blessing in preparing for Australian conditions. Whatever constraints are placed on the Indians, they should use that period to prepare cleverly and competitively.
A failure of many touring teams to Australia has been their reluctance to play competitive fixtures in the lead-up to the Tests. Too often these games are reduced to a virtual centre-wicket practice session. India need to ensure they approach any games ahead of the Gabba Test seeking victory.
India's biggest challenge will be navigating a strong Australian batting line-up. In addition to Smith and Warner, the meteoric rise of Marnus Labuschagne at No. 3 has helped solidify the batting. Australia are now far less reliant for success on big contributions from Smith and Warner.
Warner's opening partner is an area of weakness that India need to fully exploit, but keeping the "big three" quiet should be the attack's main focus.
Assuming India have a full-strength squad - three West Indies cricketers have opted out of the upcoming series in England - the touring selectors have a crucial role to play. It will help if Hardik Pandya is available. He gives India an extra bowling option to maintain the pressure when the leading fast bowlers need a rest. This is Pandya's chance to gradually build up overs in the three Tests before the SCG match, where he could act as the third seamer so that a second spinner can be included. Having Pandya at seven would necessitate Rishabh Pant keeping and batting at six.
Choosing a spinner will prove a major headache for the Indian selectors. R Ashwin has a great overall record, but not so much in Australia. Ravindra Jadeja's all-round talents and improved bowling form make him a legitimate challenger, while Kuldeep Yadav's wristspin is the biggest wicket-taking threat on Australian pitches. The decision will call for brave selections.
For Australia, the choice of bowlers is straightforward. The pace bowling is in great shape, with Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and James Pattinson forming a potent quartet. The spinner is a simple decision - Nathan Lyon and then daylight.
The batting line-up is not as clear cut. The recently announced contract list suggests Joe Burns will be Warner's opening partner. Burns is vulnerable early and this is India's big opportunity to first get at Labuschagne and then Smith while the ball is new.
Australia's middle order is an uncertain quantity, with Travis Head, Matthew Wade and Mitchell Marsh vying for two spots. That middle-order fragility highlights the rewards on offer for keeping Smith, Warner and Labuschagne in check.
Australia's strong attack should restrict India's scoring to reasonable levels despite the daunting presence of Virat Kohli and Cheteshwar Pujara. This heavyweight bout will be decided by who punches above their weight - Australia's "big three" or India's "big bats".

Former Australia captain Ian Chappell is a columnist